ArchDaily | Broadcasting Architecture Worldwidethe world's most visited architecture website
i

Sign up now and start saving and organizing your favorite architecture projects and photos

i

Find the most inspiring products for your projects in our Product Catalog.

i

Get the ArchDaily Chrome Extension and be inspired with every new tab. Install here »

h

Nominate now the Building of the Year 2017 »

All
Projects
Products
Events
Competitions
  1. ArchDaily
  2. Projects
  3. Social Housing
  4. Chile
  5. Alejandro Aravena | ELEMENTAL
  6. 2003
  7. Quinta Monroy / ELEMENTAL

Quinta Monroy / ELEMENTAL

  • 01:00 - 31 December, 2008
Quinta Monroy / ELEMENTAL
Quinta Monroy / ELEMENTAL, © Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma
© Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma

Courtesy of ELEMENTAL Courtesy of ELEMENTAL © Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma Courtesy of ELEMENTAL +20

  • Architects

    Elemental - Alejandro Aravena, Alfonso Montero, Tomás Cortese, Emilio de la Cerda
  • Location

    Sold Pedro Prado, Iquique, Tarapacá, Chile
  • Area

    5000.0 sqm
  • Project Year

    2003
  • Photographs

  • Engineering

    Juan Carlos de la Llera & José Gajardo.
  • Execution Time

    9 months
  • Client

    Gobierno regional de Tarapacá / Programa Chile-Barrio del Gobierno de Chile.
  • Contractor And Services

    Proingel, Abraham Guerra, Constructora Loga S.A.
  • Budget

    US $204 /sqm
  • Materials

    Concrete & Cement bricks
  • Constructed Area

    3500 sqm
  • More SpecsLess Specs
© Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma
© Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma

From the architect. The Chilean Government asked us to resolve the following equation:

To settle the 100 families of the Quinta Monroy, in the same 5,000 sqm site that they have illegally occupied for the last 30 years which is located in the very center of Iquique, a city in the Chilean desert.

Emplazamiento Planta Tercer Nivel Cortes Transversales Elevación +20

We had to work within the framework of the current Housing Policy, using a US$ 7,500 subsidy with which we had to pay for the land, the infrastructure and the architecture. Considering the current values in the Chilean building industry, US$ 7,500 allows for just around 30 sqm of built space.

And despite the site's price (3 times more than what social housing can normally afford) the aim was to settle the families in the same site, instead of displacing them to the periphery.

Courtesy of ELEMENTAL
Courtesy of ELEMENTAL

If to answer the question, one starts assuming 1 house = 1 family = 1 lot, we were able to host just 30 families in the site. The problem with isolated houses, is that they are very inefficient in terms of land use. That is why social housing tends to look for land that costs as little as possible. That land, is normally far away from the opportunities of work, education, transportation and health that cities offer. This way of operating has tended to localize social housing in an impoverished urban sprawl, creating belts of resentment, social conflict and inequity.

If to try to make a more efficient use of the land, we worked with row houses, even if we reduced the width of the lot until making it coincident with the width of the house, and furthermore, with the width of a room, we were able to host just 66 families. The problem with this type is that whenever a family wants to add a new room, it blocks access to light and ventilation of previous rooms. Moreover it compromises privacy because circulation has to be done through other rooms. What we get then, instead of efficiency, is overcrowding and promiscuity.

Finally, we could have gone for the high-rise building, which is very efficient in terms of land use, but this type blocks expansions and here we needed that every house could at least double the initial built space.

© Tadeuz Jalocha
© Tadeuz Jalocha

SO, WHAT TO DO?

Our first task was to find a new way of looking at the problem, shifting our mindset from the scale of the best possible US$ 7,500 object to be multiplied a 100 times, to the scale of the best possible US$ 750,000 building capable of accommodating 100 families and their expansions.

But we saw that a building blocks expansions; that is true, except on the ground and the top floor. So, we worked in a building that had just the ground and top floor.

Courtesy of ELEMENTAL
Courtesy of ELEMENTAL

Courtesy of ELEMENTAL Courtesy of ELEMENTAL Courtesy of ELEMENTAL © Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma +20

WHAT IS OUR POINT?

We think that social housing should be seen as an investment and not as an expense. So we had to make that the initial subsidy can add value over time. All of us, when buying a house expect it to increase its value. But social housing, in an unacceptable proportion, is more similar to buy a car than to buy a house; every day, its value decreases.

It is very important to correct this, because Chile will spend 10 billion dollars in the next 20 years to overcome the housing deficit. But also at the small family scale, the housing subsidy received from the State will be, by far, the biggest aid ever. So, if that subsidy can add value over time, it could mean the key turning point to leave poverty.

Diagrama
Diagrama

We in Elemental have identified a set of design conditions through which a housing unit can increase its value over time; this without having to increase the amount of money of the current subsidy.

In first place, we had to achieve enough density, (but without overcrowding), in order to be able to pay for the site, which because of its location was very expensive. To keep the site, meant to maintain the network of opportunities that the city offered and therefore to strengthen the family economy; on the other hand, good location is the key to increase a property value.

© Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma
© Cristobal Palma / Estudio Palma

Second, the provision a physical space for the "extensive family" to develop, has proved to be a key issue in the economical take off of a poor family. In between the private and public space, we introduced the collective space, conformed by around 20 families. The collective space (a common property with restricted access) is an intermediate level of association that allows surviving fragile social conditions.

Third, due to the fact that 50% of each unit's volume, will eventually be self-built, the building had to be porous enough to allow each unit to expand within its structure. The initial building must therefore provide a supporting, (rather than a constraining) framework in order to avoid any negative effects of self-construction on the urban environment over time, but also to facilitate the expansion process.

Courtesy of ELEMENTAL
Courtesy of ELEMENTAL

Finally, instead a designing a small house (in 30 sqm everything is small), we provided a middle-income house, out of which we were giving just a small part now. This meant a change in the standard: kitchens, bathrooms, stairs, partition walls and all the difficult parts of the house had to be designed for final scenario of a 72 sqm house.

In the end, when the given money is enough for just half of the house, the key question is, which half do we do. We choose to make the half that a family individually will never be able to achieve on its own, no matter how much money, energy or time they spend. That is how we expect to contribute using architectural tools, to non-architectural questions, in this case, how to overcome poverty.

Courtesy of ELEMENTAL
Courtesy of ELEMENTAL
Location to be used only as a reference. It could indicate city/country but not exact address. Cite: "Quinta Monroy / ELEMENTAL" 31 Dec 2008. ArchDaily. Accessed . <http://www.archdaily.com/10775/quinta-monroy-elemental/>
Read comments

33 Comments

heyjoe williams · October 12, 2016

FOOLS! Have they really not taken a course in concrete form design?
The decision to cast concrete shapes weighs versatility against economy. The larger the cast the greater the economy per SqFt in labor. Blocks are used often as they allow large design variation, but as the units get smaller the higher the skill level needed and the higher the labor. But these houses are all exactly the same footprint, so any decent form designer could have used sequential casting to construct walls. Further, block has a low compressive value, so it must be filled and the fill reinforced to provide needed sheer value, so, the block is the form. Did nobody there not really think to simply build a cheap reusable form and skip blocks all together?

Denise · March 28, 2015

hi is there any way that these house plans could be purchased for a fee? My house has been earthquaked in Christchurch New Zealand , and still we wait for the insurance company AIG State, to rebuild, if there are affordable plans I could build an affordable house myself. The earth quake was in 20010!

The Louisiana hurricane Katrina style for flood prone soft ground would be wonderful. Autum now snow soon.

bongane · July 31, 2012

I am a first year student at the university of cape town , i am doing a case study on the project. Coming in to it ,i thought nothing more to it that just a couple of houses fir poor people done by a famous architect but came out on the other end with a pocket full of knowledge and a great appreciation for your work. Thank you.

O?uzhan Ayd?n · June 16, 2012

Quinta Monroy / Elemental | ArchDaily http://t.co/t44zaLDH

mat webster · October 01, 2011
Dana M. Alhasan · January 23, 2011

Kept thinking about this project during the movie: http://bit.ly/xlMzD then you have the real Rio: http://wapo.st/91XqkZ #favela #cityofgod

Tha · January 22, 2011
Gintas Reisgys · December 18, 2010

Quinta Monroy / Elemental | ArchDaily http://t.co/Oww1Ega via @archdaily

rasmustorlindlampa · December 18, 2010

Quinta Monroy / Elemental | ArchDaily http://t.co/Nabhukh via @archdaily

Adam Rubin · December 18, 2010

Quinta Monroy / Elemental | ArchDaily http://bit.ly/hI6oM9

Nikola Strezovski · December 18, 2010

http://www.archdaily.com/10775... ??????????? ?? ?????? ?. ?? ??????? ?? ?? ?????? ???? ??????? ????????.

Michal Landsman · December 15, 2010

RT @MarekP: Adam Gebrian na #webexpo p?edvedl bourání klišé na krásném p?íkladu z výstavby sociálního bydlení v Chile: http://bit.ly/bYa8Wq

BoB Marvan · September 25, 2010

RT @MarekP: Adam Gebrian na #webexpo p?edvedl bourání klišé na krásném p?íkladu z výstavby sociálního bydlení v Chile: http://bit.ly/bYa8Wq

Marek Prokop · September 25, 2010

Adam Gebrian na #webexpo p?edvedl bourání klišé na krásném p?íkladu z výstavby sociálního bydlení v Chile: http://bit.ly/bYa8Wq

Joel Prada · January 19, 2010

Interesante propuesta #arquitectónica social en #Chile, pero parece que el producto final no fue el esperado http://bit.ly/xlMzD

Pierre-Yvon Carnoy · September 25, 2009

@37signals Half not half-assed houses... When architecture is "getting real": http://bit.ly/i9ngQ

wival · June 05, 2009

CONCEPTUALIZACION INTERESANTE, EJECUCION NO APLICABLE,EN MI CUESTIONAMIENTO NO ES MAS QUE OTRA MUTACION DE LA CULTURA PRESENTE EN TODOS LOS PROYECTOS SOCIALES,QUE PARECIERAN REGIRSE POR LA FORMULA " SOCIAL = HACINAMIENTO + POBREZA ",
TODO SE CONVIERTE EN UNA CARENCIA TOTAL DE ESPACIOS, EN UN ABULTAMIENTO DE MAL GUSTO, Y UNA AUSENCIA DE INTERES HACIA LOS INDIVIDUOS , QUE SON TOMADOS COMO OBJETOS " CERILLOS " QUE HAY QUE ACOMODAR EN UNA PEQUEÑA CAJA.

Monstriniho · March 18, 2010 03:19 PM

My Brothers,

You all make valid points, but we cannot stop because of your perception of failure..We are building cathedrals that we will never see completed...We must continue this noble work with the lessons learnt from the present application, Or we will be just as responsible for the failure by just criticising and not pushing the work forward...

Mis Hermanos,Hermanas.

Todos ustedes haces puntos válidos, pero no podemos pararnos debido a su percepción del fracaso.. Construimos catedrales que nunca veremos completado... Debemos seguir este trabajo noble con las lecciones aprendidas de la aplicación presente, o seremos como responsable del fracaso por sólo criticando y no empujando el trabajo avanzado...

Por favor perdone mi español malo...:)

Lu · May 14, 2009

Si.... cuando estaba en la universidad, Cali, Colombia, tome como referencia Elemental y todos los proyectos alrededor de este, los estudie y pude lograr mi proyecto de grado del cual estoy muy orgullosa y me fue muy bien, estaba muy ilusionada con conocer estos proyectos bases del mio, por cosas de la vida, llegue a Iquique por un trabajo y moria por conocer Quinta Monroy... me da pena decirlo, pero fue una gran desilucion...

Lucas · May 14, 2009

Lu, totalmente de acuerdo. Creo que la intencion es buena, pero no asi los resultados.

Lu · May 14, 2009

Buen intento, no niego lo social, y todo el estudio realizado, poer a mi consideracion falto algo de control al entregarlo a los habitantes, ahora es un proyecto horrible, super mal tenido y con poca cultura, si la idea era que cada habitante se apropiara y creara su espacio como deseara, eso lo han hecho de la peor manera y es algo de lo que la pequeña ciudad de Iquique no esta orgulloso, es un sitio lleno de ladrones y poco facil de acceder, nunca la cultura ciudadana se dio y siguen siendo lo mismo de lo mismo.

t0mash · January 29, 2009

superproject, architectural, social, e/nviron/mental

Big A · January 03, 2009

If only this kind of approach was considered more often, instead of housing projects being over developed! Let the community add to it and also add its character. If only Gehry could take this approach in the Atlantic yards project in Brooklyn, New York, which has already displaced many of the borough's inhabitants. The framework is all you need. Obviously, something that fits the New York vernacular but not with any less complexity than what Elemental has proposed and constructed. I recognize that 16 high-rise buildings in NYC represents a different scale of complexity, but it was the Brownstone building built as worker housing that has given Brooklyn much of its character. Perhaps there is an opportunity being missed to create a framework that guides the community to partake in the affairs of its own city streets, its own public life. Organic projects, such as this one by Elemental, have always established a counter to the brute force machine of the developer. Bravo.

Amelie · January 02, 2009

Tom, you are right, I follow you BUT do you think we could renegociate ''architecture without architects'' with technological apparatuses... Or do you think we just have to come back (as this project is pretending) to a ''do what you want'' with screws and dismiss ?

Tom in London · January 02, 2009

There are far too many luxurious private homes on this site, most of them built for the privileged classes in some of the poorest countries in the world (Chile, Brazil, etc.) so it's a great pleasure to see this interesting project. More of this, please ! And fewer sybaritic luxury homes in poor countries !

Benjamín · March 02, 2010 07:57 AM

Tom, Chile is not one world's poorest countries, not Brazil. u must to read more :)

DTarcho · January 02, 2009

Congratulations! this project has a good architectural thinking behind! well done!

Lucas · January 02, 2009

I think that the intention is correct. However, I consider that on the one hand there is an excessive “design” and on the other and “elemental” interpretation of the demand. Just like their name, Elemental, but in a negative sense. Also, there are interpretations that have nothing to do with local conditions. The projects are an immediate response that tries to configure a popular environment with aesthetic quality. The fact that concerns me the most is the way some units that are able to evolve over time apparently allow the users’ participation. In these projects this is the weakest aspect.The effort in the design is good and always valid, but it is not well connected with the users’ intervention. The images in is this post do not show accurately what the interventions by the users are. There is a gap there that is unresolved, that obviously, needs to be re-thought.

cam · January 01, 2009

all smart solutions were at one point in time an experiment raúl.

raúl · January 01, 2009

I find interesting to see what happen with the houses. it makes me think that it is an experiment, more than a smart solution

David Basulto · January 01, 2009

"That is how we expect to contribute using architectural tools, to non-architectural questions, in this case, how to overcome poverty."

That´s why Aravena made it to the Monocle Magazine 20 heroes list.

David Basulto · January 01, 2009

archizoo,

Interesting link. Thanks!

archizoo · January 01, 2009

Delightful innovation! Check out this (http://designthinking.ideo.com....

Contemporary Art · January 01, 2009

I agree, this looks great. Homes anyone could be proud of.
--
http://www.contemporaryartdail...

roadkill · January 01, 2009

Still one of the most resourceful and best affordable housing projects ever... Well done - let's have some more drawings please!

···

Comments are closed

Read comments