“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs

“BEFORE/AFTER” documents the drastic changes, both physical and psychological, which took place during the renovation of Beijing’s Fangjia Hutong in the months between April and September 2017. In 2019, OPEN Architecture was invited to participate in “Unknown City: China Contemporary Architecture and Image Exhibition”, the opening exhibition of the Pingshan Art Museum, with their work “BEFORE/AFTER”.

After the renovation, the diverse storefronts that used to record the joyful moments of life were removed and replaced with rows of uniform building façades. The Hutongs that used to hold numerous cafes, restaurants, bars, and featured shops suddenly lost its own identity. 

OPEN Architecture’s “BEFORE/AFTER” attempts to use image comparisons to encourage people’s reflection on a series of critical urban issues—of freedom and authority, progress and nostalgia, inclusivity and exclusivity, collectivity and individuality, and ultimately, the future of our cities. Through this study, OPEN Architecture hopes to encourage discussions around the definition of the ideal urban living and urban fabric.

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 36 of 45
a Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 37 of 45
a After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Li Hu, the founding partner of OPEN Architecture, is also an architect who has worked in Fangjia Hutong for many years. After witnessing the radical changes that have given Fangjia Hutong a makeover, Li Hu argues that most renovation works done on Fangjia Hutong, focused on beautifying the existing facades, based on some assumptions about historic characters of Hutong.

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 24 of 45
Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Li Hu points out that, when it comes to heritage restoration and urban planning, we have always been paying too much attention to the “looks” instead of the “stories” the buildings tend to carry throughout time. Our cities are never just a beautifully decorated postcard, cities are living and full of our life stories.

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 38 of 45
b Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 39 of 45
b After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

For example, if you pass through the freshly renovated building skin along both sides of the Hutong, and enter from the back, where real stories happen, you will realize that old messy life dramas are still on show within the complex. The shiny tiling on the exterior face of the building does not have anything to do with what’s really happening in the back. In fact, everyday, the residents of Hutong have to walk all the way to the streets to access public washrooms, having to go through life with low dignity.

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 40 of 45
c Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 41 of 45
c After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

The question that remains is: are we just creating nice-looking buildings in the context, or are we really designing for people who have to live and use the structures everyday? Actually, design should be human-centered instead of policy-driven; because eventually, we should be designing a way of living, not a way of "looking".

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 42 of 45
d Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 43 of 45
d After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 2 of 45
03 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 14 of 45
03 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 4 of 45
11 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 17 of 45
11 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 19 of 45
09 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 16 of 45
09 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 23 of 45
07 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 12 of 45
07 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 28 of 45
14 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 29 of 45
14 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 32 of 45
16 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 33 of 45
16 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 7 of 45
05 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 13 of 45
05 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 15 of 45
01 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 8 of 45
01 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 20 of 45
06 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 21 of 45
06 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

Before versus After

“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 9 of 45
02 Before. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs - Image 6 of 45
02 After. Image Courtesy of OPEN Architecture
About this author
Cite: Scarlett Miao. "“BEFORE/AFTER”: An Architectural Documentation of Urban Changes in Hutongs" 26 Aug 2020. ArchDaily. Accessed . <https://www.archdaily.com/946062/before-after-an-architectural-documentation-of-urban-changes-in-hutongs> ISSN 0719-8884

Courtesy of OPEN Architecture

“BEFORE/AFTER”: 北京胡同改造的摄影纪实

You've started following your first account!

Did you know?

You'll now receive updates based on what you follow! Personalize your stream and start following your favorite authors, offices and users.