the world's most visited architecture website
i

Sign up now and start saving and organizing your favorite architecture projects and photos

Sign up now to save and organize your favorite architecture projects

i

Find the most inspiring products for your projects in our Product Catalog.

Find the most inspiring products in our Product Catalog.

i

Get the ArchDaily Chrome Extension and be inspired with every new tab. Install here »

i

All over the world, architects are finding cool ways to re-use run-down old buildings. Click here to see the best in Refurbishment Architecture.

Want to see the coolest refurbishment projects? Click here.

i

Immerse yourself in inspiring buildings with our selection of 360 videos. Click here.

See our immersive, inspiring 360 videos. Click here.

All
Projects
Products
Events
Competitions
Navigate articles using your keyboard
  1. ArchDaily
  2. News
  3. Are Luis Barragán's Ashes More Important Than His Life's Work?

Are Luis Barragán's Ashes More Important Than His Life's Work?

Are Luis Barragán's Ashes More Important Than His Life's Work?
Are Luis Barragán's Ashes More Important Than His Life's Work?, Una pieza de la exposición. Image Cortesía de Museo Universitario de Arte Contemporáneo
Una pieza de la exposición. Image Cortesía de Museo Universitario de Arte Contemporáneo

In a somewhat poetic proposal, Jill Magid, the American artist, offered Federica Zano, owner and archivist of the Barragan Foundation in Switzerland, a two-carat diamond ring made from ashes from Barragan’s cremation, in exchange for returning Barragan’s professional archive to Mexico.

This gesture was the pinnacle of an art project that “posed fundamental questions about the consequences and implications of converting cultural legacy into private corporate property.” Magid’s work, titled “A Letter Always Arrives at its Destination,” held an exhibition at the University Museum of Contemporary Art at the UNAM.

I recently visited the exhibition and bumped into an acquaintance in the second room. She was overwhelmed by the number of pieces in the exhibit but had not seen the famed and controversial ring, and asked me if I’d seen it. I responded that it was also my first time at the exhibit but that it would probably be in the last room. She left abruptly without saying goodbye. As is common with contemporary art, this piece had caused fierce debate; in this case, it was about its origin. The dispute surrounding the piece overshadowed its content, but someone has to say it: Luis Barragán's ashes are not more important than his life's work. 

When I arrived in the last room, I was pleased to see the ring mounted unpretentiously, similar to the other pieces surrounding it. To review again the topic that the project explores: “the consequences and implications of converting cultural legacy into private corporate property,” I ask myself, where is the indignation for the fact that this important part of Mexico´s architectural heritage is jealously guarded abroad? 

Cena que organizó la artista con la familia de Luis Barragán. Image Cortesía de Museo Universitario de Arte Contemporáneo
Cena que organizó la artista con la familia de Luis Barragán. Image Cortesía de Museo Universitario de Arte Contemporáneo

A lot has been spoken about the Barragán family, who, previously unaware of the project, were shocked to find out about the piece´s contents. But my intention is not to discuss them, or the ring, or the Catholic faith to which Barragán professed, which has made recent headlines. But rather, I want to focus on the Robles Castillo House, his first formal piece of architecture that now is a taco stand, and the rest of his “lost” work in Guadalajara. The real scandal is that the Mexican government hasn't acquired and protected his work as architectural heritage and that his professional archive abroad by Zanco has been rebranded as Luis Barragan (without the accent). 

It is worth asking while we discuss the ethics of converting ashes into diamonds: who should guarantee that we are not losing something more valuable? 

Cite: Zatarain, Karina. "Are Luis Barragán's Ashes More Important Than His Life's Work?" [Las cenizas de Luis Barragán no son más importantes que su obra y archivo] 10 Jul 2017. ArchDaily. (Trans. Devine, Sophie) Accessed . <https://www.archdaily.com/875306/luis-barragans-ashes-arent-more-important-than-his-lifes-work/> ISSN 0719-8884
Read comments