ArchDaily | Broadcasting Architecture Worldwidethe world's most visited architecture website
i

Sign up now and start saving and organizing your favorite architecture projects and photos

i

Find the most inspiring products for your projects in our Product Catalog.

i

Get the ArchDaily Chrome Extension and be inspired with every new tab. Install here »

All
Projects
Products
Events
Competitions
  1. ArchDaily
  2. Projects
  3. Social Housing
  4. Mexico
  5. ELEMENTAL
  6. 2010
  7. Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL

Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL

  • 00:00 - 9 March, 2010
Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL
Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL, © Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez

© Ramiro Ramirez © Ramiro Ramirez © Ramiro Ramirez © Ramiro Ramirez +44

  • Engineering

    Area of projects and technological innovation, IVNL
  • Client

    Instituto de la Vivienda de Nuevo León (IVNL)
  • Urbanization & Specialization

    Area of projects and technological innovation, IVNL
  • Initial House Area

    40 sqm
  • Expanded House Area

    58.75 sqm
  • Initial Duplex Area

    40 sqm
  • Expanded Duplex Area

    76.60 sqm
  • More SpecsLess Specs
© Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez

From the architect. Restrictions

Santa Catarina is a city of 230,000 inhabitants, located in the state of Nuevo León, in the northwest of Mexico. This project is Elemental’s first outside of Chile.

© Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez

The Government of Nuevo León, México, commissioned us to design a group of 70 homes on a site of .6 hectars in a middle class neighborhood in Santa Catarina. The required density suggested the application of the typology we developed for Iquique. However, the climate in Santa Catarina is very different from the northern dessert climate of Chile. The 600 mm of annual rainfall required us to adapt our proposal to this new question.

Exploded Axonometric
Exploded Axonometric

The commission to develop this middle class neighborhood with the financing of US$20,000 per dwelling (almost double the funds we had for the housing projects built by Elemental in Chile). However, the construction standards and building codes significantly raise the construction costs. In this case, it was pertinent to use the strategy of investing state resources to build “the difficult half” of the home, especially given the capacity do-it-yourself building observed in Mexico, ensuring a promising future for the expansions.

© Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez

The Project

ELEMENTAL Monterrey consists of a three-story continuous building that in section superimposes a home (first floor) with a two-story apartment above (2nd and 3rd story). Both units are designed to technically and economically facilitate the final middle class standard of which we will hand over the “first half” (40 m2). In this sense, the difficult parts of the house (bathrooms, kitchen, stairs, and dividing walls) are designed for the expanded scenario, that is, for a home of more than 58 m2 approx. and an apartment of approximately 76 m2.

© Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez

Secondly, given that almost 50% of the m2 of the complex will be self-built, this building is porous so that the growth can occur within the structure. On one hand we want to frame and give rhythm (more than control) to the spontaneous construction so as to avoid deterioration of the urban environment over time, and also make the process of expansions for each family easier. The proposed continuous roof above the volumes and voids protects the expansion zones from rain and ensures a definitive profile of the building toward the public space.

First Floor Plan
First Floor Plan
Second Floor Plan
Second Floor Plan
Third Floor Plan
Third Floor Plan

Third, experience tells us that in lower class neighborhoods the green spaces tend to be “earth spaces,” due to the scarcity of maintenance and the distance that exists between green space and the home that makes it difficult for neighbors to take care of. What we did in this case was to surround the green space with building, reducing the distance between communal space and the home to a minimum. This permitted us to define a collective space with secure Access that gives space to the social network and generates favorable conditions for maintenance and care.

© Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez

All the apartments have direct Access from the public space and parking, a condition especially relevant in a country where every family can have access to an automobile.

© Ramiro Ramirez
© Ramiro Ramirez
Location to be used only as a reference. It could indicate city/country but not exact address. Cite: "Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL" 09 Mar 2010. ArchDaily. Accessed . <http://www.archdaily.com/52202/monterrey-housing-elemental/>
Read comments

27 Comments

Paco Morales · April 06, 2016

It still doesn´t work... In Monterrey prevails the same lack of cultures and budget to make people step up from their situation, a project of housing like this unfortunately lasts a few months to become the sames as its surrounding...another favela.
see it for yourself:
https://www.google.com.mx/maps...

diesel cars · July 18, 2014

Why viewers still use to read news papers when in this technological globe all is accessible on web?

mutuelle chien · April 19, 2014

I do not know whether it's just me or if perhaps everyone else experiencing issues with your blog.
It looks like some of the written text within your posts are running
off the screen. Can someone else please comment
and let me know if this is happening to them
too? This might be a issue with my web browser because I've had this happen before.
Thanks

dola · December 21, 2013

"earth spaces".....the project is lovely indeed!

medicare supplemental insuranc · March 10, 2013

The Huffington Station speaks to this influential interview via requires that medigap plans
insurers remark many consumer protections.

Vic Barr · December 13, 2012

Love this, great solution for social housing!

Star Of David Necklaces · June 21, 2012

It's actually a great and useful piece of info. I am glad that you simply shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

Anna · April 05, 2012

I'd really like to see some photos of what it looks like now, to see if the idea did in fact work... It is a great idea!

Giles Holt · October 05, 2011

Example of appropriate architecture: Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL | ArchDaily http://t.co/ttB1KVHK via @archdaily

YIP · April 27, 2010

I like this project. It reminds me those 1920s projects in Paris by Le Corbusier.

Monterrey · March 13, 2010

The Housing Institute of Nuevo Leon in colaboration with the architecture firm ELEMENTAL, have done the first progresive vertical housing complex in the country. This Project is an example that is possible to realize a more dense prototype of social housing instead of the usual individual plot that Mexico´s social housing projects is used to. Congratulations to the Housing Institute for pursuing this kind of ideas, and also to the ELEMENTAL firm because it seems that they fully understand the context of Monterrey.

Oscar · March 12, 2010

I'm from Monterrey. The people this project is designed for live barely above the poverty line. This is GREAT, because it is also designed to add to it in the future, if needed, if possible.

fernando · March 10, 2010

yes reminds me Bouça, from Alvaro Siza
http://www.mimoa.eu/projects/P...

niko · March 10, 2010

The presentation here would make more sense if it comprised an ecomomic appraisal, to explain the construction cost of these "1/2 homes" in comparison to just building finished, low cost units for social rent or state-assisted purchase. It would also be interesting to hear a cultural/demographic argument for making people self-build. This process obvioulsy rules out a huge percentage of the population as tenants/home owners if you are unable to build yourself or pay for the extension. Also, if houses are designed for social tenants, likelyhood is higher than average that tenants will be old, disabled or otherwise challenged in which case the mighty staircase leading to your front door could prove insurmountable... I like the self-build idea taken from 60s experimental architecture, but it should not be done for its aesthetics rather for its economic & social value.

bLogHouse · March 10, 2010 11:30 PM

@niko
I agree with you - the self-build idea should not be done for its aesthetics and I think that's precisely what we have here - a project with a solid economic and social reasoning. At first I thought the authors were after getting an aesthetic effect from combining the controlled design done by the architect with the looser, more spontaneous design done by each inhabitant. Although this might be a part of their intentions, their primary concerns seem to be financial and social. Here's a quote from their expose:
"The commission to develop this middle class neighborhood with the financing of US$20,000 per dwelling (almost double the funds we had for the housing projects built by Elemental in Chile). However, the construction standards and building codes significantly raise the construction costs. In this case, it was pertinent to use the strategy of investing state resources to build “the difficult half” of the home, especially given the capacity do-it-yourself building observed in Mexico, ensuring a promising future for the expansions."
As you said, not a new idea, but a great one, nevertheless.

Simone · March 10, 2010

I have seen the first image and BOOM, Alvaro Siza copy!

François · March 12, 2010 02:17 PM

Totally the same!

But Siza's is better!

Rick S. · March 10, 2010 03:31 PM

LOL. You're funny. I'm sure that, someday, you'll see how silly is that comment.

pcs · March 10, 2010

look at iquique, in about two years this project will be totally different, the white and the rigor will be gone and it will be very lively. i suppose the yellow painted apartment is the first starter ...
for this approach i love elemental's and aravena's courage.

roh · March 10, 2010

i really appreciate the rigor to this. the project was clearly conceived and executed with a large idea behind it. well done.

Dustin · March 10, 2010

ARCHDAILY can you please explain why my comments always get deleted? It was in English and it was a good argument with nothing worthy of moderation. Thank you.

Bocetos Digitales · March 10, 2010

Monterrey Housing / ELEMENTAL: © Ramiro Ramirez
Architects: ELEMENTAL
Location: Monterrey, Mexico
Client: Institut... http://bit.ly/ct5ugd

Lil Jimmy · March 10, 2010

I love the mtns...too bad all that sprawl sits below them...

ygogolak · March 10, 2010

I guess I'm missing the reasoning behind the huge exterior staircase. As an engineering feat they are impressive, aesthetically they look out of place to me.

toto · March 10, 2010

Great architecture, but i don't underdstand how completing the volume can be more economic than building it alltogether in the first place! Also, the caracter of this building is determined by the voids and the transparency with the inner court (that will be lost), even if i doubt they will ever manage to plant trees.

Pablo C · March 10, 2010

Excuse my ignorance, but will the new structure (floor) not damage the original structure? or how will that be done? can someone explain for me, thankyou

elSkarquitecto · March 10, 2010 04:57 AM

A lot of people in Latin America are knowledgeable in pouring concrete slabs, in fact, in certain places a concrete is cheaper than steel framing. You can notice the pre-constructed beams in the exterior walls for that slab. It is probably engineered for the extra structure.

For insulation if this is in the tropics and you have 8" block walls and no air conditioning you do not need insulation. Just open the jalousie window, and turn on the cheap fan, maybe open the door.

Take the chance and look outside your country. Not everyone lives and constructs the same.

totto · March 10, 2010 02:58 AM

Yeah and what about continuity of insulation? Everything is more expensive if completed afterwards

Dustin · March 10, 2010

The execution is OK. I don't believe the intention is very good though. Why do you want a big monotonous building? I know, it happens a lot in Mexico where people add on to their basic home and the result is less than desirable (horrible details, ugly decorations, disproportionate forms, etc...), but I believe that is what gives houses in Mexico character, Mexicans are full of character and traditions, their homes should reflect that even though we as architects cant find the immediate beauty.
Basically what the architects did was create a monotonous form, and made sure that the building would ALWAYS be monotonous, they seem to believe every family has the same needs, customs and desires. How wrong.
I do like the idea of the inner courtyard, although it could also become a dangerous place because it is enclosed and out of view from the authorities eye. (think vandalism, violence, drugs, etc..).

taller.componente · March 10, 2010 10:15 PM

@dustin...
I just don´t understand how do you believe that the intention of giving houses to the people that don´t have any access to loans, credits, or to buy by any chance a house, because they make less than $100 us dlls a week, it is NOT good... and you say that you know that what happens a lot in Mexico? horrible details, ugly decorations, disproportionate forms? well is their fault, they missed the most important classes when they were in architecture school right? I think i disagree with you when you say that the building would be ALWAYS monotonous, and i agree when you say that every family has different needs, that is why, the building NEVER would be monotonous, every one would add their own character to the complex. And just so you know, even when every family has different needs, customs and desires, they share the same principal need, the need of having a house to live in, can you imagine how many people could we help making each house according to each user? (obviously in terms of social housing). I know it would be hard to understand because the level of your standards, and the kind of houses that we´ve (you and me) lived on, but when you see how this people live, the cost of this houses compared to what would cost this wherever you live, against what this people make, you´ll understand that this is a very good first step for them to keep moving fordward, and chasing their dreams. I´m sorry if i sound rude, is not my intention, but i wanted you to know a little bit more about this project, before you speak your mind again, about our city and our culture. I know this project, and i´ve been there, and belive me is not as bad as you think it is. Have a good week.

jorge · March 10, 2010

Are you kidding???? this is a total rip off from Alejandro Aravena's work in Chile, for social housing, is exactly the same without the roof and difference in materials.

Mario Prz · August 26, 2010 07:35 AM

Alejandro aravena is part of ELEMENTAL´s design team, I wouldn't call it a ripoff...
Its more like a repeated formula of space organization for horizontal condominiums.
Only time will tell if its appliable to different surroundings.
-it worked perfectly in Chile.

taller.componente · March 10, 2010 10:20 PM

@jorge
please visit http://www.elementalchile.cl/

Diego Pinochet · March 10, 2010 02:59 AM

Aravena is the mind behind elemental.... hope u were kidding

kaji45 · March 10, 2010 01:22 AM

LOL I hope that is irony.... you do know who is excecutive director of elemental? Anyways.. this is another great example that architecture can exist in the humblest of structures.

josecarlos · March 10, 2010

love this project, hope all of the social housing around latin america could be as good as this ones

mark · March 09, 2010

ohhh my!!! what is that? this is not architecture, please help us and free us for this kind of architecture, obiously is for latinamerican countries... so bad!!

Mario Prz · August 26, 2010 07:28 AM

mark, do you even know what architecture is about? That is, in its most elemental purpose, to serve the need for a shelter.
If you could understand that the need of a house/apartment in that (this) city, is increasing exponentially, AND that this team´s propposal is absolutely efficient in terms of space optimization and flexibility, for a low-cost housing project, you would be ashamed of your post. Not to mention they are also Latin. capital L like the one on your forehead.

Please help us and free us of your pathetic, dispectful comments, and STOP discriminating.

j · March 10, 2010 04:31 PM

poor idiot. its functional and i could even feel a real special atmosphere winding through the park and buildings

adrian · March 10, 2010 08:04 AM

pobre mark. anyway.....
Look for this proyect under "quinta Monroy" Iquique, Chile by Alejandro Aravena.
total rip off.

Balkan · March 09, 2010 11:50 PM

@Mark if u would use your brain a little instead of ur eyes and read u would know the real value of this project.

···

Comments are closed

Read comments
© Ramiro Ramirez

蒙特雷住宅 / ELEMENTAL