Agaticeva St. / Randić & Turato
Architects: Randić & Turato / Saša Randić and Idis Turato
Location: Rijeka, Croatia
Collaborator: Gordan Resan
Project Year: 2008
Photographs: Robert Leš
The residential and office building in Agatićeva Street is a kind of filling for a long time desolate hole in the very centre of the town, which also opened the new pedestrian stretch that connects the Korzo with the northern end of the Delta. It is a detached house that concludes the row of houses on the northern border of Rijeka’s Old Town.
axo
The structure is an interpretation of anonymous city architecture with a geometrised envelope as the main feature that finds its logic in the geometry of Stealth planes. This envelope is continued from the façade to the roof, where large skylights are opened mechanically.
plan 01
In the program sense the structure did not have defined contents until it was finished, so that it was planned in the way to enable interaction of different private and public programs. At the end of all program changes, the building was turned into a polyclinic, while apartments were moved to the fourth floor and under the roof. The apartments have a separate access to the common courtyard on the fourth floor.
-
- model
-
- model
-
- plan 01
-
- plan 02
-
- section
-
- axo
-
- perspective
Perhaps the worst piece of architecture i’ve seen.
Perhabs the meaningsless comment I ever read.
I agree, MZ. The comment seems to imply little more than personal, subjective dislike. We are left wondering if the critic has ever seen some of the developer-driven EIFS
postmodernist jobs built all over the USA, if he calls this
the worst he’s seen.
This building rigidly abides by the height, massing, and
urban-plan logic of its context. So far, nothing out of the ordinary. However, the highly unusual and provocative “restrained” grammar of the skin seems to be turning many
people off.
Perhaps if one doesn’t like the skin, present some arguments as to why you think it doesn’t work?
agree with alex^
simply awful!
Me too.
me too
One might call this “awful” or “ugly”, but I see several interesting things:
- Several architects, including many well-known, are trying the “volume wrapped in a skin” concept these days, and this one is really not the worst of them, at least here it makes sense because it is like “wrapping” part of the old building
- In whole Europe there is the very hard question of how to behave in historical contexts, do you really need to mimic older stuff in order to avoid “disrupting” the “harmony”? I think this project is a sensitive tentative to give a contemporary answer, because it is low-profile and strong at the same time
- Of course we should see more of the project, but the first picture gives me a feel of modernist architecture which is something I like much in Eastern Europe countries because it is still regarded with consideration there.
Maybe this building doesn’t make a statement, but I think it melts on the surrounds in a ver appropiated way.
Being silent can be a quality too, especially when we are getting used to see the buildings (and the architects!!) screaming their presence.
By the way, I completely agree with you Yorik.
meni se ovo sviđa. moderno je i lijepo a uklapa se u okoliš što nije bilo nimalo lako napraviti.
“Finds its logic in the geometry of stealth planes”? Oh come on. Far from being “silent”, this building screams “shallow” and “inappropriate”.
I don’t understand the significance of the stealth plane (has it been developed there?), but I do like the modest nature the architecture assumes. From the aerial photographs, it took me a few seconds to actually locate the building: it fits well with its surroundings on that scale.
I would have liked to see a shot of the common courtyard (it was important enough to include it in the description) and the pedestrian space underneath.
Agaticeva St. http://bit.ly/4zYE6y
One of their worst projects. They do like to experiment with facades that usually dont corespond to the plans and sections, but this time they did make a failure.
Très beau projet.
Bonne et pertinante réponse sur une parcelle assez difficile…
I found this building to absolutely have no sensibility to it’s surrounding, and to have very aggressive-dull impact on it. All in all I think it’s a failure.
i want to ask someone responsible to admin commente where is my comment!!! i dont see it offensive to anyone. It was the first submitted comment here.
Thanks
11:03 PM Dec 14th
ArchDaily: Agaticeva St. / Randić & Turato http://bit.ly/7Tv2Qu
11:20 PM Dec 14th
Agaticeva St. / Randić & Turato: Architects: Randić & Turato / Saša Randić and Idis Turato Location: Ri.. http://tinyurl.com/yb3rg6z
11:21 PM Dec 14th
Agaticeva St. / Randić & Turato http://bit.ly/5BwCI2