ArchDaily | Broadcasting Architecture Worldwidethe world's most visited architecture website
i

Sign up now and start saving and organizing your favorite architecture projects and photos

i

Find the most inspiring products for your projects in our Product Catalog.

i

Get the ArchDaily Chrome Extension and be inspired with every new tab. Install here »

All
Projects
Products
Events
Competitions
Navigate articles using your keyboard
  1. ArchDaily
  2. News
  3. The Restoration of Chartres Cathedral is a "Scandalous Desecration"

The Restoration of Chartres Cathedral is a "Scandalous Desecration"

The Restoration of Chartres Cathedral is a "Scandalous Desecration"
The Restoration of Chartres Cathedral is a "Scandalous Desecration", On the left, an as-yet unrestored section of the cathedral can be compared to a restored section, right. Image © Flickr CC User Lawrence OP
On the left, an as-yet unrestored section of the cathedral can be compared to a restored section, right. Image © Flickr CC User Lawrence OP

Throughout its eight-century-long history, Chartres Cathedral has been consistently cited as one of the world's greatest religious spaces, charming countless architects thanks to its dramatic interior combining brooding stone vaults and delicate stained glass windows. But this legacy is severely threatened, argues Martin Filler for the New York Review of Books, by a "foolhardy" restoration in its zeal for recapturing the past "makes authentic artifacts look fake."

© Flickr CC User Lawrence OP The stark difference between the original and the restored sections. Image © Flickr CC User Sarah Karlson © Flickr CC User Connie Ma A gilded boss at the top of a vault. Image © Flickr CC User Klaus Wagensonner + 6

© Flickr CC User Connie Ma
© Flickr CC User Connie Ma

Despite minimal evidence of the cathedral's original interior color scheme, and despite the fact that this color scheme has been forgotten for well over five hundred years, the French Ministry of Culture’s Monuments Historiques division is pressing ahead with a scheme to paint the interior white, with trompe l’oeil marbling and gilded detailing, in an effect that Filler compares to "some funeral parlor in Little Italy." He writes:

"Whereas the old, age-darkened masonry heightened the intense colors of the windows, the new paint subverts them. As Adrien Goetz wrote in Le Figaro last month (in one of the very few critical accounts of the overhaul in France), the new effect is like “watching a film in a movie theater where they haven’t turned off the lights.”"

The stark difference between the original and the restored sections. Image © Flickr CC User Sarah Karlson
The stark difference between the original and the restored sections. Image © Flickr CC User Sarah Karlson

Read more about this "unfolding cultural disaster" at the New York Review of Books.

Cite: Rory Stott. "The Restoration of Chartres Cathedral is a "Scandalous Desecration"" 16 Dec 2014. ArchDaily. Accessed . <http://www.archdaily.com/578212/the-restoration-of-chartres-cathedral-is-a-scandalous-desecration/>
Read comments