Alternative to Piano’s Whitney Museum / Axis Mundi

©

Axis Mundi … remember that firm?  Back when controversy surrounded Jean Nouvel’s proposed tower for the MoMA’s expansion, the firm offered an alternative stacked design highly different from Nouvel’s metallic creation. It seems  Axis Mundi is back for the shock value as the firm has just released images for their version of the new of American Art.    The current design, led by Renzo Piano, utilizes his characteristically light and technical aesthetics (check out his Shard which is under construction) to create an elegant addition critics have challenge may be too “timid” – Axis Mundi’s design is anything but.  Their proposal incorporates a loud exoskeleton that not only seems completely out of scale, but also fights with its neighborhood for attention rather than settling into its context.   The geometry, which has been shaped by the sight lines and street grid of the city, intends to reference Breuer’s Whitney on Madison Avenue.   As The Architect’s Newspaper Blog noted, the proposal mentions nothing of cost – one of the biggest obstacles Piano is facing.

Check out more images of Axis Mundi’s proposal after the break.

© Axis Mundi
© Axis Mundi
© Axis Mundi
© Axis Mundi
Cite: Cilento, Karen. "Alternative to Piano’s Whitney Museum / Axis Mundi" 21 Sep 2010. ArchDaily. Accessed 24 Nov 2014. <http://www.archdaily.com/?p=78635>
  • Archy

    This is scary. I would prefer Renzo’s proposal any day over this.

  • randomHero

    It has to be some sort of urban street pattern?
    Really don’t like this.

  • Dennis

    THE HORROR…

  • Well

    Dystopically looking like a strung heap of whatever, squeezing out the inside for no particular reason.
    Too much strainig for effect, too much to be beautiful.

  • Well

    And i wonder if Robocop pops out a corner when you accidentially throw down a cig

  • Richard

    Hands down. Renzo wins. ‘A bull in a china-shop’ comes to mind.

  • a

    There’s only one nice thing here: Jeff Koons’s work. Is it legal to use somebody’s work to promote our own? Just a question.

  • Leonardo Ximenes

    There are no plans here, so let’s discuss looks…
    First of all, I don’t blame anybody for not liking it. And have to say, Piano is my favorite architect.
    Having said that, I can’t believe but…I love this! Pushy, extravagant, kitsch, and original: so NY! Its facades balance between shambles and sophistication, respectively references to the Meatpacking District’s recent past and future aspirations. And what’s best, Gehry’s not involved! :)

  • brb001

    Based on the five pictures above, I rather like the Axis Mundi design. It has a boldness that actually is evocative of the upper east side Whitney and I like what appears to be an integration of exterior space into the building near the Highline. I’m curious to see more now.

  • sf

    i think its bold…. its like a sculpture..
    no wait.. tone it down…

    lets have less personality and become more sterile…

    we should not have character… merely a seamless blend of…

    • Dennis

      yes let’s build this design because of its PERSONALITY.

      what’s wrong with you?

  • bLogHouse

    Looks like a package, made by Wall.e
    Can’t deny – has character!

  • http://www.archilocus.com archilocus

    Ha! They were probably paid by Piano so people would accept his last horrendous design. Didn’t work for me, Renzo !

  • Zombiebunny

    So what does Renzo Piano have to do with this building? I mean, he’s not listed anywhere on the design team, the Axis Mundi website, or really, anywhere. So what part is he playing in all this?

    • Well

      Read the headline.

      ;)

  • Arkcg

    is diferent , I like it

    • ozmoto

      Street corner view is very cool. I like it also.