Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects

Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
Tel Aviv based Chyutin Architects have won a competition for the new Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem. The project will replace a previous scheme done by Frank Gehry. More images and architect’s description after the break.
The Museum of Tolerance is located at the heart of modern Jerusalem, in its rejuvenated city center, on the borderline between the spacious Independence Park, and the urban built environment. The location is a meeting site of three main streets which differ in character and function. Hillel street: a bustling commercial zone; Moshe Ben Israel street: a road crossing the park; and Moshe Salomon street- Nachalat Shiva’s pedestrian mall, a tourist hub, full of restaurants and shops.
The buildings surrounding the museum site have diverse architectural characteristics, representing the history of Jerusalem architecture from the 19th century up today. We wanted the MOTJ building to be integrated into the landscape without overshadowing the preexisting urban setting on the one hand, while asserting its own unique character on the other, an iconic structure that reflects transparency and openness and generates visual interest at close and distant views. The MOTJ is to act as a bridge between the different architectural styles present in its location on one hand, while stylistically using contemporary architectural language and exploring advanced technology and materiality. We wanted the MOTJ building to stand in the warm embrace of the urban fabric and the park around it, shinning as a jewel set to the skyline of Jerusalem.
The MOTJ building is planed to host a variety of different activities: exhibition spaces, an education center, a theater, a multipurpose hall, offices, a restaurant, a gift shop, etc. The activities are diverse in the types of visitor communities they serve, in their operating hours, in their environmental requirements and in their interaction with the urban context. The developed building concept answers the requirements of each specific activity, encouraging undisturbed access for the various communities to their appropriate destinations.
We designed an elongated structure which traces the southern and eastern borderline of the site. The structure orchestrates the three surrounding streets, into a coherent urban space-a new public square for the rejuvenated city center of Jerusalem. The design of the public square incorporates several different elements: a sunken archeological garden, enclosing the remains of the roman aqueduct discovered at the site’s center, a terraced amphitheater, a grove and various public paved areas, for the various activities of visitors.
The building is divided into two horizontal wings: a three floors floating upper wing which hosts the theater and social meeting spaces, and a two floors lower sunken wing which hosts the children and the adult museums exhibition spaces- the so-called “dark box.”. The entrance floor is located at the level of the public square hosts a restaurant and gift shop. The entrance floor is leading up to the floating wing or down to the sunken one. A four-leveled lobby connects the floating wing and the sunken one. Part of the floating wing is suspended over ground level, creating a gap, a doorway, from the built city to the park. Pedestrians who are relaxing in the public square or walking towards the park may be enticed to enter the MOTJ building and experience it.
The archeological garden serves as an outdoor space for the sunken wing, contributing to the activities of the exhibition spaces. The garden is connected to the street level by a terraced slope which can be used as a seating area for outdoor performances. It has 1200 seats capacity.
The architectural language of the MOTJ building sets it apart from its backdrop as a visual icon, while still maintaining continuity in terms of building height and materials with the urban fabric around it. The location of the building on the borderline between the city and the park dictates the design of the building facades. In accordance with municipal regulations, the building facades towards the city are stone-clad, and they exist in dialogue with the 19th and 20th century stone houses beside it. Towards the park, the structure has glass facades, which relate to the glass park façade of the future courthouse. The stone structure floats over the gap and the glass walls of the building’s entrance. This allows for visual continuity between the city and the park, preventing the building from becoming an impenetrable barrier. The design of the facades, the roof and underbelly as a geometrical envelop that connects folded stone-clad planes may be understood as echoing the geographical form of Jerusalem as a city surrounded by mountains.
The differences in design between the city and park facades diversify and enrich the structure’s visual appearance. Walking around the building may create an element of surprise.
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects
- Courtesy of Chyutin Architects


























































![Hans Hollein / Peter Weibel [HG. | ED]](http://ad009cdnb.archdaily.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/1329220171-img-3775-125x125.jpg)









Tolerance!?
That’s a good one :DDD
Disarm, you hypocrites
disarm? who r u to gudge them you are the hypcrites
where r u from europe? usa? australia? u all killed murderd and conquered all the world for centuries and in case u havent noticed this is a ARCHITECTURE site
This is AN architecture site :) How old are you? Evidently not old enough to type the entire word ‘you’.
Architecture encapsulates and represents IDEAS.
The idea that is being presented here is not convincing in the wider context.
Lets see how impressed Palestine and Lebanon are to your sugary frosting-pale slab of untruth on its hill.
What is wrong with Gery’s proposal?…
I suppose it was a giant… expensive… leaky sieve made out of titanium… and the client… realized it.
Put tolerance into a museum instead of living it. Nice try and way to go, Israel.
Seems to me like a true first-year-architecture-lesson of how two projects in the same location with nearly the same program can be so different from one another;
The noisy-wedding-cake-like project by FG, and that modern yet calm, contemporary but not trendy suggestion made by this office.
two words to sum up the project in many ways… empty space.
More like the Museum of Intolerance- this is one of at least two politically controversial Israeli projects being constructed over Islamic/Palestinian grave sites- this perhaps being the reason Gehry left the project.
It’s difficult to see this museum outside of the political context that exists in Israel today- peace talks have collapsed as a moratorium on Israel’s expanding settlement construction into Palestinian lands and around Jerusalem (forcing Palestinians living in East Jerusalem out of their homes) ends, Israel’s Foreign (born) minister recently gave a speech to the UN suggesting the ‘population transfer’ (read-ethnic cleansing) of the 20% of Isreal’s Palestinian to somewhere else. And in todays news, Israel is pushing for “loyalty oaths” for it’s Palestinian inhabitants to declare allegiance to a Jewish and ethnocratic state.
As a museum of “tolerance” one would sort of expect this to somehow be reflected in it’s design as opposed to its contents alone, but as one looks closer to Israeli society this “tolerance” seems more likely aimed at the west in yet another PR campaign in asking it to turn a blind eye on what is looking more and more like a racist apartheid failed state- or, as Gideon Levy coined in Haaretz yesterday- “The Jewish Republic of Israel”
So, aside from all the other popular western architecture intentionisms, that the architect states he wishes to ‘integrate the building into the landscape’ makes me wonder what this “tolerance” is all about, or if the real aim is simply another attempt at erasing Palestinian culture.
It would be nice if people wrote their comments in the sites language…
what if all of a sudden a project in Chile only had spanish comments, a project in Brazil only had portuguese comments, a project in Poland only had polish comments…
Some respect please.
No wonder you’re in a bunker.
It is incredibly common to see comments in the language of the projects’ location. Nothing to comment on – unless of course you’re looking for a way to frame some slanderous verbal vomit.
google Tel Aviv
who r u to gudge them? you are the hypcrites!
where r u from europe? usa? australia? u all killed murderd and conquered all the world for centuries and in case u havent noticed this is a ARCHITECTURE site
What kind of a tolerance is it?
israeli tolerance.
Much better than arab “tolerance”, (but its really a greveyard it should be respected no matter if its arab, jewish, catholic or any other religion) but speaking about tolerance..at least isrealies doesnt explote buses full of people in israel or metro stations in london or rail stations in madrid, or buildings in the USA, embasies in Africa..should I continue?? killing thousends of civilians and inocent people Is everybody blind, doesnt have any memory or just ignorants? thats your concept of tolerance?? :-(
‘Museum of Tolerance’ built upon Muslim graveyard on appropriated land…
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/israel-plans-to-build-museum-of-tolerance-on-muslim-graves-466028.html
It will never be “tolerance” to build this base on Muslim gaveyard ,specially in Jerusalem
This is an architecture website, it seems like a good ARCHITECTURAL project! for all of you commenting about political ideologies please do it in an other forum..you are the ones that doesnt show any tolerance and respect..roberto, santiago,mootymoo,headless, meliha duran, mert yilmaz, zack..etc.. imagine this project wasnt in israel..what if this project was in china, london or any othe country… then it will be a good proposal..?? wow.. how sad…(and im not israeli, neither jewish)
i agree with what “alon” said i think that all of u attack israel by saying that they are racist and intollorent but the fact that u choose to attack them without saying a word about the project itself means that actually u r the racist ones and i also agree with was he said about you being the bleeding hearted hypcrites. im also not an israeli and i cant say that i agree with all of what the israelis do but i cant judge them cause i know what my country’s history isn’t better (spain)
samefag
if it was in china, it wont be built on the graves of the rightful owners of the site.
am sorry but its not about religion or nationality, humane feelings demand the respect for the dead, and the respect of the rightful owners of a place. plz take your time to understand the full scope of the issue.
Isn’t architecture supposed to be the point of coalescence between other fields of study (ie. art, science, politics, religion, philosophy)? Understanding architecture in those terms, then this project is extremely shallow, and certainly not a good proposal. Although, it might wow some critics on a 2nd year project. It’s unfortunate and disappointing when the rawness of human life is overlooked in our built environment.
see comment above.
Architecture carries cultural weight precisely because of the IDEAS it represents.
Greenhorn.
The building is disconnected from its enviroment, no relation with the site or enviroment-the wrong proposal-
and no one need at all this museum
ואני מוכן להגיד גם בעברית(
טמבל שמאלני יפה נפש לך קיבינמט
וזה עושה זאת טוב יותר?
בורות גרועה, לא התיחסת כלל לכתווב
riccardoMX – since when was architecture not a political act ? You’re asking us to disregard everything architecture is about AS WELL as context ?!
Museum of Intolerance disrespects the Muslim graves – that’s why Gehry pulled out.
In the wrong country.
Firstly, they have presented us with everything, in terms of the fashionable image and renders, yet no plan of the building and more importantly, plan of the city showing the character of the city or the context in which the building sits, which they waffle on for, in the second paragraph. If it so important, present it for viewing. The third paragraph mentions openness and transparency to the city, yet the cartoon suggests that the intention for that gross, closed elevation is toward the city, while the ‘openness’ leaves you staring at a forest at close range(the last render). How is that captivating? The presentation is very disparate, with a model and renders and then a number of cartoons. On a purely architectural experience, this ‘museum’ could adequately work as any type of warehouse in the future, as the experiential nature of this building is banal with a very questionable and ambiguous form of the roof, which doesn’t impact on the visitors experience of the museum at all(they are being very generous with the impact of the light in those sections from those tiny roof-lights). Without the plan, I assume form has been the driver behind the strategic planning and it looks like a lot of unused space. This proposal is dross, and thats not to even deal with the social impact or its background. I hope the city dwellers can tolerate this.
architecture and politics cannot be separated, if you kick people out of their homes based on their race (Arabs in this case) and say its to “revitalize” the city center, how can one possibly detach himself from that and try to judge or look at this project (which is a part of the so called revitalization) ??????
the whole thing is a part of a racist statement, and its the viewers right to know so, shame on the so called architect.
what do u know about arabs being kicked from their homes have u ever been to israel, have u lived in that area or do u clame rhis “facts” from cnn, bbc or youre youre own head
all u know about this subject is what u hear on youre “tabloid” tv news ( cnn, bbc, fox and so on)
actually, am Jordanian!
i have many friends from Jerusalem, and i do know a thing or two about how people were kicked (and still get kicked) from their homes.
big surprise!!!!! Arabs have architects!!
bigger surprise!!! Arabs do exist!!!!!
momen the fact that u have friend in east jerusalem dosent mean nothing let me tell u something when jewish are being kicked from their homes in jerusalen do to lack of building permit no one says nothing but when arabs are kicked do to the same reason cnn films it and says that israel is trying to take over arab houses thats what reallt haapens u HYPOCRITE DONK
F U
relax!!!!
we r all civilized people here (@ least some of us are!!)
c thats typical Israeli mentality, just yell loud and deny internationally established facts; (israel want to kick original arab residents from Jerusalem)
and 4 heavens sake, use spell check; ur English is terrible!!
Gehry’s proposal was an amazing, experiencial building that took risks, and had some tremendous moments in it. This one is yet another boring grey box. Why would anyone choose this? Its promoting mediocrity….
nice outer shape, nice images, but the inner spaces seem quite weak in terms of articulation
what is the façade material? is there a system detail?
ALL OF THOSE WHO HAD TO CURSE ISRAEL INSTED OF TALKING ABOUT ARCHITECTURE READ maria eugenia COMMENT THAT SHOULD SHUT U BLEEDING HEARTED HYPOCRITES UP WELL SAID MARIA WELL SAID :)
If only there were something more intense and impactful than ALLCAPS, the ‘architecture as politics’ camp could really get WIN here. Alas. Alon, you really nuked this argument with your profound and insightful remarks.
This should be called ‘Museum of Intolerance’. Read Saree Makdisi’s “The Architecture of Erasure”; & also “A Racialized Space: Social Engineering in Jerusalem,” in Contemporary Arab Affairs, vol. 2, no. 4 (October-December, 2009), pp. 566-75.
More info here:
http://pulsemedia.org/2010/02/17/mamilla-campaign/
http://pulsemedia.org/2009/10/15/a-museum-of-intolerance-in-jerusalem/
Tim.
11:09 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/cy6u0i
11:09 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/cy6u0i
11:09 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/cy6u0i
11:09 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/bE0cfj
11:09 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/bE0cfj
11:09 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/bE0cfj
11:13 PM Oct 10th
RT @ArchDaily: Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
11:13 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin ArchitectsTel Aviv based Chyutin Archit… http://bit.ly/bE0cfj
11:14 PM Oct 10th
RT @ArchDaily: Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
11:24 PM Oct 10th
RT @ArchDaily: Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
11:30 PM Oct 10th
#Architekt #Calau Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin A… http://bit.ly/b2ND3u #in http://dy.cx/c03
11:39 PM Oct 10th
RT @archdaily: Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
11:46 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects via ArchDaily – Courtesy of Chyutin Architects Tel … http://tinyurl.com/27co8f5
11:52 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Tel Aviv based Chyutin Architects have won a competition fo… http://bit.ly/cy6u0i
11:52 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Tel Aviv based Chyutin Architects have won a competition fo… http://bit.ly/cy6u0i
11:52 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Tel Aviv based Chyutin Architects have won a competition fo… http://bit.ly/cy6u0i
11:55 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin Architects Tel… http://goo.gl/fb/3glPR
11:55 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin Architects Tel… http://goo.gl/fb/3glPR
11:55 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects: Courtesy of Chyutin Architects Tel… http://goo.gl/fb/3glPR
11:57 PM Oct 10th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/mkSrEt2 via @archdaily
12:35 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects – Tel Aviv based Chyutin Architects have won a competition for… http://ow.ly/19nPOm
2:44 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://bit.ly/9fWjZB
3:06 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/JCnLZd6 via @archdaily
3:26 AM Oct 11th
RT @ArchDaily: Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
4:35 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily: Tel Aviv based Chyutin Archi… http://bit.ly/cy0r92 http://www.cubestudio.info
4:42 AM Oct 11th
Lindo conceito: Museu da Tolerancia, em Jerusalem. Via @ArchDaily: http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
4:44 AM Oct 11th
Projeto IV – Museu da Tolerância em Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/Fy2TV9F via @archdaily
5:32 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/EswGA9R via @archdaily
7:30 AM Oct 11th
RT @ArchDaily: Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://archdai.ly/bpmlZB #architecture
8:18 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/9wMv0Y4 via @archdaily
8:42 AM Oct 11th
Beautiful plans for the new Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem – http://bit.ly/dmORzy via @archdaily
8:45 AM Oct 11th
RT @inbalhotel: Beautiful plans for the new Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem – http://bit.ly/dmORzy via @archdaily //can I say I hate them?
9:41 AM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/ey6PoTN via @archdaily
1:25 PM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/UArcwA9 via @archdaily
3:00 PM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/SZzn5oj vía @archdaily
4:50 PM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/mPSRBin via @archdaily
7:36 PM Oct 11th
Musem of Tolerance in Jerusalem http://www.archdaily.com/81319/museum-of-tolerance-in-jerusalem-chyutin-architects/
8:00 PM Oct 11th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/pcVVqnO via @archdaily
11:16 PM Oct 11th
Reading: "Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily"( http://twitthis.com/wzv695 )
9:31 AM Oct 12th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem. http://bit.ly/dcPlYh
10:01 AM Oct 12th
RT @nicholaspatten eum of Tolerance in Jerusalem. http://bit.ly/dcPlYh
10:03 AM Oct 12th
RT @nicholaspatten Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem. http://bit.ly/dcPlYh
9:38 PM Oct 12th
WOW Moment of #Architecture of the day: Museum of Tolerance in #Jerusalem http://t.co/oYhwpet via @archdaily
10:54 PM Oct 12th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/zt1lsPi via @archdaily
5:03 AM Oct 13th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/VeWSly7 via @archdaily
2:55 AM Oct 22nd
http://tinyurl.com/2g2hsqe We like this simple and elegant design by Chyutin Architects
7:06 PM Oct 25th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects http://t.co/bU89fDS via @archdaily
4:01 AM Dec 18th
@gonzalocorreal http://bit.ly/9xb2Il, concepto similar a nuestro proyecto
12:36 AM Mar 29th
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/dekY8Ii via @archdaily
3:33 PM Dec 21st
Museum of Tolerance in Jerusalem / Chyutin Architects | ArchDaily http://t.co/AuAe6Z3D via @archdaily