Musée National des Beaux Arts du Québec proposal / Barkow Leibinger Architekten with Barkow Leibinger Architects, Berlin with Imrey Culbert Architects
We have been featuring several proposal for the Musée National des Beaux Arts du Québec competition. Along with the winning project by OMA, we’ve featured proposals by Saucier + Perrotte Architects and the submission by BIG + Fugère Architectes. Today, Barkow Leibinger Architekten shared with us their proposal, done with NY based architects Imrey Culbert Architects. More images and architect’s description after the break.
Our proposal recognizes the Musee National des Beaux-Arts du Québec as an ensemble of distinctive pavillons of diverse historical identities that constitute a cultural-campus in the Parc des Champs de Bataille. Rather than an “institutional monument” we propose a new building as an “integrated cultural fabric” in the form of a matt structure, that is, a double-story exhibition and public forum that enables flexible and well-integrated spaces for experiencing art or for public discourse. The new museum is integrated directly with the existing historical church and presbytére anticipating their future integration programmatically into the museum; the church tower remains as the landmark for the immediate site. The new pavilion references both an industrial architecture with north-facing shed roofs with the building clad in brick recalling the local tradition of building in brick and stone. The opaque brick upper volume houses gallery spaces floating above a transparent ground level which functions as a public concourse.
Urbanistically the new museum-pavilion covers the entire available site in order to allow as much horizontal continuity (therefore flexibility and adjacency) as possible. Its primary public circulation route aligns with the radial center located by the monument at the traffic circle, at the conclusion of the Avenue Wolfe-Montcalm. From this center to the tower of the church a diagonal line of movement is established: the main entrance is located at the south corner of the building site protected by the upper level floor, which forms a canopy. This location establishes a close physical and visual proximity to the neighboring and existing museum as well as to the existing parking. This entrance location helps draw the ensemble of buildings into a spatial and urbanistic continuity.
The entrance spaces continue along the diagonal organization to an event space, the auditorium, which replaces the former interior courtyard of the monastery as a programmatic center to the existing and new museum spaces. This multi-use space will offer a new public center to the project integrating the church (for future museum spaces) and the presbytére. A wide stair near the entrance connects to the tunnel below connecting to the other pavilions.
booring, go oma
Musée National des Beaux Arts du Québec proposal. http://bit.ly/aN0c6w
RT @nicholaspatten MuséNational des Beaux Arts du Quéc proposal. http://bit.ly/aN0c6w
This is a good, urban building. It’s well-proportioned for the surrounding context, not trying to dominate the area like the other schemes. While I do like OMA’s scheme, I really like the straightforwardness of this submission. It’s pretty solid. Good work!
ok – yes boring… but definitely a couple of big moves which are nice. The building is less massive and more sensitive to the adjacent church than OMA.
beautiful. i’m not a fan of OMA’s scheme.
sections blew me away
definitely my favourite entry
That is a great conection to the churh nearby. And it is a better solution then OMA’s.
the best one!
7:19 PM Apr 23rd
Musée National des Beaux Arts du Québec proposal / Barkow Leibinger Architekten http://tinyurl.com/22ntv27
8:20 PM Apr 23rd
Musée National des Beaux Arts du Québec proposal / Barkow … http://bit.ly/cpvksL